Electron Storage in Electroactive Biofilms

Intermittent operation of bioanodes influences electron storage in the electroactive biofilm.Longer-term carry over polymers is an unexplored mechanism.Microbial electrochemical technologies are unique because electrodes provide a new way to control biological conversions.Understanding may ways influence selectivity biotechnological processes. Microbial (METs) promising for sustainable applications. Recently, during intermittent biofilms (EABs) has been shown play important role power output and efficiencies. Insights into mechanisms, conditions under which these occur, essential improve microbial conversions optimize Here, we discuss two main mechanisms EABs: form reduced redox active components transport chain polymers. We review EABs other microorganisms will how can be influenced. To safeguard Earth’s resources future generations, it utmost importance reduce our CO2 footprint recover valuable from waste streams reuse. address this huge challenge, develop mature technologies. have applications resource energy recovery bioremediation [1.Logan B.E. et al.Microbial electrolysis cells high yield hydrogen gas production organic matter.Environ. Sci. Technol. 2008; 42: 8630-8640Crossref PubMed Scopus (875) Google Scholar, 2.Logan fuel cells: methodology technology.Environ. 2006; 40: 5181-5192Crossref (4323) 3.Santoro C. fundamentals A review.J. Power Sources. 2017; 356: 225-244Crossref (787) 4.Kuntke P. al.(Bio)electrochemical ammonia recovery: progress perspectives.Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 2018; 102: 3865-3878Crossref (74) Scholar]. METs collectively refer systems that use combination (see Glossary) different conversions. The key property they transfer electrons between chemical bonds electrodes, serve many [5.Erable B. al.Application electro-active biofilms.Biofouling. 2010; 26: 57-71Crossref (91) Scholar,6.Lovley D.R. Nevin K.P. shift current: concepts microbe-electrode exchange.Curr. Opin. 2011; 22: 441-448Crossref (166) Scholar] (Box 1).Box 1Microbial Electrochemical Technologies (METs)METs collective term (Figure I). molecules (chemical bonds) [3.Santoro Scholar,5.Erable Scholar,9.Hamelers H.V.M. al.New performance bioelectrochemical systems.Appl. 85: 1673-1685Crossref (200) Scholar,57.Rabaey K. Rozendal R.A. electrosynthesis – revisiting electrical route production.Nat. Rev. 8: 706-716Crossref (993) cell, electricity wastewater, classical illustration MET [2.Logan biofilm anode called bioanode. At bioanode, acetate (as model component wastewater) oxidized CO2, protons, IA). Electrons transported cathode where acceptor, like oxygen. Alternatively, electrons, extracted at anode, via microorganisms. biocathode, IB), protons (microbial cell) [57.Rabaey Scholar,64.Nevin electrosynthesis: feeding microbes convert carbon dioxide water multicarbon extracellular compounds.mBio. 1e00103-10Crossref (586) This provides energy. studied decades, one remaining challenge increase reactions occurring order take next step towards practical application [7.Sleutels T.H.J.A. al.Low substrate loading limits methanogenesis leads Coulombic efficiency systems.Microorganisms. 2016; 4: 7Crossref (37) 8.Georg S. al.Competition electrogens with methanogens bioanodes.Water Res. 2019; 170: 115292Crossref (10) 9.Hamelers 10.Janicek A. al.Design application: analysis scale-up studies.Biofuels. 2014; 5: 79-92Crossref (123) In METs, competing (microbial) processes occur lower desired reactions, including methanogenesis, sulfate reduction, oxidation/reduction metals. These mainly due complex nature nutrient media applied types systems. normally expressed as Scholar,11.Molenaar S.D. acetogens biocathodes: comparison potentiostatic galvanostatic control.Int. J. Mol. 18: 204Crossref (30) Scholar,12.Molenaar al.Comparison counter rechargeable battery.ChemElectroChem. 6: 2464-2473Crossref (5) For both biocathodes, efficiencies highly variable [13.Sleutels al.Effect operational parameters on systems.Bioresour. 11172-11176Crossref (103) When balances do not add up 100%, used processes, example, (aerobic or anaerobic) intermediates byproducts formate [12.Molenaar Another process leading efficiencies, received much attention, EABs. electrode potential parameter obtain stable efficient biocathodes [14.Heijne Environmental science ecotechnology bioelectrochemistry flexible processes.Environ. Ecotechnol. 2020; 1: 100011Crossref (2) potentials controlled fixed level (continuous polarization) alternating open-circuit closed-circuit (intermittent polarization). During bioanodes, more charge harvested structure compared continuous [15.Deeke al.Capacitive enable renewable cells.Environ. 2012; 46: 3554-3560Crossref (124) Scholar,16.Zhang X. al.Periodic polarization increases current density carriers concentration while modifying structure.Biosens. Bioelectron. 121: 183-191Crossref (26) methane-producing also improved when was [17.Liu D. al.Granular carbon-based cathodes systems.Front. Bioeng. 78Crossref (27) circuit open, stored released closed again. Besides enhancing EAB performance, could potentially efficiency. All studies point out interesting differences behavior currently poorly understood. describe effects EABs, identify microorganisms, compare reported 1, Key Figure). operation, maintained period (where no flow), followed by circuit. Current after repolarization shows peak, combined result rate release cytochromes, metabolic activity [18.Bonanni P.S. al.Charge accumulation kinetics Geobacter sulfurreducens biofilms.Energy Environ. 6188-6195Crossref (81) capacitive first Deeke coworkers They showed activated (10 min on, 20 off), reached average 0.12 mA/cm2 (2.2 C/cm2 30 min), whereas same produced 0.093 (1.3 min). Such mode Zhang [16.Zhang tested charging times (open circuit) 0.1–600 seconds, discharge time 60 found maximum steady-state delivered 1.1 mA/cm2, 0.4 continuously polarized related substantial carrier (10.6 ± 0.5 mMe– vs. 2.9 0.6 mMe–). chain, such cytochromes quinones. recent years, interest increased 19.Schrott G.D. al.Electrochemical insight mechanism sulfurreducens.Electrochim. Acta. 56: 10791-10795Crossref (93) 20.Uría N. al.Transient Shewanella oneidensis MR-1 growing cell.Environ. 45: 10250-10256Crossref (64) 21.Zhang al.Reversible periodic anodic biofilms.ChemElectroChem. 1921-1925Crossref 22.Deeke al.Influence thickness layer cells.J. 2013; 243: 611-616Crossref (49) 23.Gardel E.J. al.Duty cycling generation multi-anode environmental 5222-5229Crossref (43) Kubannek measured measure [24.Kubannek F. al.Revealing respiring bacteria differential mass spectrometry.Bioelectrochemistry. 160-168Crossref even open-cell conditions, product formed, being produced, thus converted cellular metabolism continued. results imply oxidation directly coupled. allows proceed acceptor available. addition, acetate, though stops. higher recovery, morphology polarization. mushroom-like structures their top layers, grown were flat study dominated species. group changes only visible exposed longer than 10 days [21.Zhang Regarding species significant effect presence observed. However, led Bacteroidetes [23.Gardel Two identified 2): polymeric substances, polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHAs) [25.Nishio al.Extracellular enhances polyhydroxybutyrate productivity Ralstonia eutropha.Environ. Lett. 40-43Crossref (23) Scholar,26.Freguia al.Electron reveal temporary bacterial generation.Environ. 2007; 41: 2915-2921Crossref (201) Scholar], cell components, [27.Busalmen J.P. al.C-type wire electricity-producing electrodes.Angew. Chem. Int. Ed Engl. 47: 4874-4877Crossref (164) Scholar,28.Liu Y. Bond Long-distance G. c-type cytochromes.ChemSusChem. 1047-1053Crossref (96) located surface flavins [29.Okamoto al.Cell-secreted bound membrane dictate surfaces diverse pH.Sci. Rep. 5628Crossref (92) 30.Kotloski N.J. Gralnick J.A. Flavin shuttles dominate oneidensis.mBio. 4e00553-12Crossref (249) 31.Light S.H. al.A flavin-based Gram-positive bacteria.Nature. 562: 140-144Crossref (196) either proteins wall free. and, some extent, quantified, but contribution overall flows remains unknown. It likely strongly depends frame polarization; polymer expected timescales, shorter-term process. Ter Heijne quantified change capacitance using impedance spectroscopy growth constantly [32.Ter al.Quantification bio-anode spectroscopy.J. 400: 533-538Crossref (22) bioanode 450 ?F cm–2, noncapacitive (fluorinated tin oxide, FTO) without had 25 cm–2. explained surface, would give direct response perturbations. Malvankar developed gold detected 600 course 50 [33.Malvankar N.S. al.Supercapacitors based conductive nanostructured networks living bacteria.ChemPhysChem. 13: 463-468Crossref (133) Also, several analyzed constant [34.Bueno P.R. al.Biochemical biofilms.ChemSusChem. 2015; 2492-2495Crossref (4) Scholar,35.Guo al.Impact electrode-respiring biofilms.J. 406: 96-101Crossref (9) studies, major separate capacitance, especially high-capacitance materials graphite felt 33.Malvankar 34.Bueno Scholar,36.Ter al.Analysis through spectroscopy.Bioelectrochemistry. 106: 64-72Crossref (36) occurs short timescale (less seconds). Several focused elucidating storage. Esteve-Núñez fluorescence technique status evaluate capacity [37.Esteve-Núñez al.Fluorescent properties extracytoplasmic sink sulfurreducens.Environ. 10: 497-505Crossref (181) Fernandes NMR periplasmic [38.Fernandes A.P. al.Interaction insights pathways sulfurreducens.Biochem. 474: 797-808Crossref (11) Capacitance has, best knowledge, studied. Most prokaryotic store insoluble intracellular polymers, polyphosphate (polyP), polysaccharides glycogen, poly-?-hydroxyalkanoates (PHAs), triacylglycerol (TAG), wax ester (WE) [39.Shively J.M. Prokaryote inclusions: descriptions discoveries.in: Shively Inclusions Prokaryotes. Springer, 2006: 3-20Crossref compounds usually formed widely available element terminal supply. PolyP granules synthesized phosphate storage, PHAs, TAG, WE reserve compounds. Glycogen (multibranched polyglucose) PHA [composed (R)-hydroxy fatty acids] most common wide, taxonomically range prokaryotes (bacteria archaea) Scholar,40.Wang L. al.Bioinformatics archaeal reserves.Sci. 9: 1034Crossref (19) Storage TAG (ester derived glycerol three acids) acid alcohol) Actinomycetales Gram-negative [41.Castro A.R. al.Oil hydrocarbon-producing bacteria.in: Stams A.J.M. Souza D.Z. Biogenesis Hydrocarbons. Handbook Hydrocarbon Lipid Microbiology. 2019: 471-487Crossref PHAs Scholar,42.Srikanth al.Microaerophilic microenvironment biocathode electrogenesis simultaneous synthesis (PHA) system (BES).Bioresour. 125: 291-299Crossref (41) Freguia [26.Freguia occurrence transient lipophilic inclusions, fed pulses. fraction transiently external resistance, resistance preferable diversions synthesis. source, (PHB) synthesized. Acetate acetyl coenzyme (acetyl-CoA), acetoacetyl-CoA condensation acetyl-CoA. Acetoacetyl-CoA NADH (or NADPH) 3-hydroxybutyryl-CoA then polymerized PHB [43.Yamane T. Yield poly-D(-)-3-hydroxybutyrate various sources: theoretical study.Biotechnol. 1993; 165-170Crossref (152) required supplied circulating acetyl-CoA tricarboxylic (TCA) cycle (NAD+ + 2e– H+ ? NADH) reduction investigated (acetate) relation PHA, too low (<–0.5 V Ag/AgCl) immediate oxidation. afterwards (0.2 V) applied. Substrate observed oxygen limitation [42.Srikanth Sc